In recent months, the lithium market has witnessed a notable shift as prices that seemed to soar uncontrollably have finally shown signs of stabilizationThe meteoric rise of lithium carbonate, once hovering near an unfathomable 600,000 yuan per ton in November, has taken a sharp downturn, plummeting to around 532,500 yuan per ton by late December, according to data from Shanghai Steel UnionThis decline highlights a broader trend that has caused concerns within the industry and among investors alike.
Historically speaking, the journey of lithium prices has been tumultuous, marked by volatility and speculative frenziesPrior to 2015, the global price of lithium remained relatively low, around 40,000 yuan per tonThis picture began to drastically change with the advent of electric vehicles (EVs), which catalyzed demand and sent prices soaring
Advertisements
Major lithium producers like Pilbara and Altura ramped up production efforts to meet the surging need, only to be met with their own set of challenges down the road.
The excitement of rising prices soon gave way to stark realitiesBy 2018, the enhanced supply was sufficient to bring prices crashing back down to levels not seen in a decadeThe high-cost miners, unable to sustain operations under these conditions, were forced to leave the market entirelyCompanies like Bald Hill and Wodgina went bankrupt, while others, such as Altura, were acquired under dire circumstances, further consolidating market forces.
In the midst of supply tightening, demand for EVs exploded, particularly in China, fueling a once-in-a-lifetime expansion within the sectorThe figures speak volumes about this change; in 2020, shipments of positive electrode materials in China totaled merely 500,000 tons, but by 2021, that number had skyrocketed to over 1.11 million tons, with production capacity reaching 1.7 million tons
Advertisements
The excitement was palpable — yet, the timeline for increased manufacturing capacity for upstream lithium resources failed to align, fostering an environment ripe for instability.
Estimates from the International Energy Agency indicated that bringing lithium spodumene mines in Australia from discovery to operational status typically takes around four years, while South American salt lake operations can extend this process to approximately seven yearsIn stark contrast, the time required to develop production capabilities for positive electrode materials is significantly shorter, usually around one yearSuch disparities in timelines exacerbate the imbalance between production capacities at various stages of the supply chain.
Reflections from the photovoltaic industry echo this paradox — rapid expansions in component manufacturing met with lagging raw material supply led to explosive price increases for silicon
Advertisements
A similar situation unfolding in the lithium market has only deepened supply chain disruptionsBy 2021, the price of lithium carbonate surged by over 430%, and as the following year began, these trends intensified further, with prices jumping from 280,000 yuan to above 500,000 yuan per ton within a mere three months, nearly doublingThe weight of these costs added substantial financial burdens to EV producers, with each vehicle requiring about 30-50 kilograms of lithium carbonate alone.
The dramatic rise in prices has placed significant pressure on companies trying to balance operational costs without unfairly burdening consumersDespite ongoing price hikes from virtually every EV manufacturer, consumer pushback has been evident, indicating a potential market fatigue with rising costsIssues like semiconductor shortages, compounded with soaring lithium prices, present unprecedented challenges for the automotive industry.
Recognizing this increasing tension, industry experts and insiders worry that the current trajectory may ultimately prompt negative repercussions for upstream suppliers
- 18% Annual Return
- U.S. Stock Market Appears Overvalued
- Bank of Japan Raises Interest Rates on Friday
- A-Shares Poised for Major Shift
- Rising Pressure on Yen’s Decline
If production costs surpass acceptable thresholds for both manufacturers and consumers, a cooling off period in the market could ensue, causing ramifications that might lead to reduced demand and subsequent price declines.
Interestingly, factors beyond pure supply and demand dynamics appear to influence the current marketLi Bin, the CEO of NIO, remarked on a call discussing their financial results that there are significant speculative elements at play regarding the lithium price hikesIn a capital-driven era, the valuation of commodities such as lithium often tapers more towards speculative attributes rather than foundational supply and demand metrics.
Exemplifying this phenomenon, Pilbara, Australia’s largest lithium miner, held an auction in May 2022, selling spodumene concentrate at an astonishing price of $5,955 per ton
This marked the fifth auction by the company since the previous yearSuch auction results, however, do not necessarily reflect actual market conditions, especially considering that mainstream concentrate prices for lithium stood around $3,100 per ton in April — indicating a significant discrepancy.
The auction dynamics appear more strategic than a reflection of genuine market health, with miners like Pilbara potentially signaling future price increases, thereby stoking speculation in the wider marketSimilar actions recently from the Snovey mine, while not significantly impacting supply chains, send ripples of uncertainty that can lead to dramatic shifts in market sentiment.
From a long-term perspective, sustaining the ongoing bullish trend in lithium pricing seems increasingly untenableThe reality remains that the world does not suffer a shortage of lithium resources; considerable deposits exist
According to the United States Geological Survey, the proven lithium reserves were estimated at 2.2 million tons of lithium equivalent in 2021 — a figure that dwarfs current demand projections.
For context, the global lithium demand in 2020 was around 330,000 tons of lithium equivalentPredictions suggest that even with rising demand from the EV sector, this figure is projected to grow only modestly to approximately 1.24 million tons by 2025. Ultimately, the existing lithium resources can accommodate global needs for potentially over a century, an oversupply scenario present in stark contrast to current market trends.
Lastly, while upstream companies such as Ganfeng Lithium and Tianqi Lithium have reported staggering growth rates in revenues — surging 291% and 536%, respectively, in the third quarter of 2022 — the associated costs of burgeoning prices have yet to find a stable equilibrium